🥧 Holiday orders are open Pies, cookie trays, sausage & hams · Order now →
Mayse Farm Market Mayse Farm Market Evansville, Indiana · Est. 1940 812-963-3175
Down on the Farm Bakery

Holiday bakery order

Pies and cookie trays, made fresh for your holiday table.

Order form

Place your order

Tell us what you would like from the bakery. You will pay when you pick up. Questions? Call 812-963-3175.

Cut off time for BAKERY ONLINE ordering - Monday, November 23rd

Have you ordered from us before?

Contact information

Please provide all contact information below.

Pickup window

Closed Thanksgiving Day, Thursday, Nov 26th.
Please select your pickup window
Only if you chose Other above.

Farm fresh pies

Need more than 10? Please call the farm at 812-963-3175.
Traditional pie crust topping
Crumbly topping
Apples, Rhubarb, Strawberries, Red Raspberries, Blackberries

Yeast breads & cinnamon rolls

All bread is unsliced.

Assorted cookie trays

Our assorted cookie trays are freshly prepared with a variety of bakery favorites. Cookie selections are made by our bakery, but we will do our best to accommodate preferences based on availability. Need more than 10? Please call the farm at 812-963-3175.
Want a mix? Tell us in the special requests box below.
Want a mix? Tell us in the special requests box below.
Please note: Price may increase based on cookie preferences.

Need sausage or ham too?

Each order has its own form, so we can get it to the right kitchen.

Go to the sausage & ham form

Good to know

  • You will pay for all orders upon pickup.
  • Unable to pick up? Please notify the market 4 days prior, or as soon as you can, so we do not fill your order.
  • For large orders or special requests, call us at 812-963-3175 so we can talk through details and availability.

Market hours

  • Monday Closed
  • Tuesday–Friday 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Saturday 9:00 AM – 12:00 PM
  • Sunday Closed

We reopen Tuesday, November 24th and stay open through mid-January 2027. Christmas Eve 9 AM – 12 NOON. Closed Thanksgiving, Christmas, December 26th, New Year’s Day and January 2nd.